Wednesday, 14 September 2011
The Gall
Watched with interest Arnab Goswami interview Anna Hazare between 2030 and 2100 hrs last night. It was gratifying to see that the septuagenarian did not falter even once during the grilling at the hands of this seasoned anchor. Arnab did not spare a chance to trip the simple man. He was worse than the BBC's Hard Talk veteran Tim Sebastian in so far as his tone, tenor and language, bordering on the impudent, carefully adding "Ji" to Anna but smiling all the same when he thought he had asked a difficult question. Wonder if Arnab will ever treat a ruling party member or a minister with such tone that bordered on rudeness and I say this after having watched him question Mr Pranab Mukherji who is usually quite short tempered.
Saturday, 10 September 2011
Sir, Please dont insult our intelligence
The government and its agencies continue to be completely clueless about the likely perpetrators of the Delhi High Court bomb blast. It is clear that terrorists are becoming more and more emboldened with every strike that goes unpunished or unsolved.
We are told the investigative agencies are working round the clock. If only those charged with preventing terror had worked round the clock, the attack would not have taken place in the first place. We need to send some police officers and ministers to the UK and the US to learn how both have managed to keep their respective countries terror free over some five/ten years.
Unless those in authority lose sleep over this problem, terrorism will not be stopped.
We are masters at closing the barn doors after the horses have bolted.
Strangely, all those waxing eloquent against the civil society during the recent JLPB agitation are strangely tongue tied. Not a whimper, no condemnation, no ideas, no advice, no sloganeering, no pledges!!! Sad Sad Sad no?
We are told the investigative agencies are working round the clock. If only those charged with preventing terror had worked round the clock, the attack would not have taken place in the first place. We need to send some police officers and ministers to the UK and the US to learn how both have managed to keep their respective countries terror free over some five/ten years.
Unless those in authority lose sleep over this problem, terrorism will not be stopped.
We are masters at closing the barn doors after the horses have bolted.
Strangely, all those waxing eloquent against the civil society during the recent JLPB agitation are strangely tongue tied. Not a whimper, no condemnation, no ideas, no advice, no sloganeering, no pledges!!! Sad Sad Sad no?
Wednesday, 7 September 2011
Delhi Blast
Another bomb blast; this time outside the High Court. HUJI has allegedly taken responsibility and threatened more such blasts if a certain man convicted in the December, 13, 2001 Parliament Terror Attack is not released. Whatever the truth but one thing is clear: India cannot afford to inordinately delay important decisions nor can it make vague excuses of our Democratic and judicial system being responsible for the same.
While investigations and court trials take time our leadership must not delay their decisions hoping to derive some political or other benefit.
People will demand and get a bigger contingent of police outside the High Courts; tomorrow it will be District Courts. How many policemen can we spare?
As I have repeatedly said "terror must be stopped at the gates", and homegrown terror has to be fought on a daily basis and not when a blast takes place. Investigation and deterrent punishment are of course very important but prevention is far more so. if it means that more and more people/organizations/groups have to be brought under close surveillance then it cannot be avoided.
Unless the people in charge of security take their duties more seriously we cannot defeat terror.
Finally, if the government is squeamish about enforcing law, it might as well abolish death penalty and accept the consequences.
Today we a great big country with big aspirations are looking like 'pushovers', something the law minister said last week that we are not.
While investigations and court trials take time our leadership must not delay their decisions hoping to derive some political or other benefit.
People will demand and get a bigger contingent of police outside the High Courts; tomorrow it will be District Courts. How many policemen can we spare?
As I have repeatedly said "terror must be stopped at the gates", and homegrown terror has to be fought on a daily basis and not when a blast takes place. Investigation and deterrent punishment are of course very important but prevention is far more so. if it means that more and more people/organizations/groups have to be brought under close surveillance then it cannot be avoided.
Unless the people in charge of security take their duties more seriously we cannot defeat terror.
Finally, if the government is squeamish about enforcing law, it might as well abolish death penalty and accept the consequences.
Today we a great big country with big aspirations are looking like 'pushovers', something the law minister said last week that we are not.
Friday, 2 September 2011
Not a Pushover
According to TOI of 01 Sep, 2011, Shri Salman Khurshid has said that the government might have lost some ground but would soon regain it. "We are not pushovers". Commendable if it means that the GOI has taken the Civil Society challenge seriously and will curb/eliminate corruption.
In many other areas including national security, GOI appears to be a 'pushover' as it invariably avoids retaliatory action. Does not even declare its intention to discipline the offender.
While I am not suggesting that India should resort to use of military force at the slightest provocation/threat, there is an urgent need to at least warn the habitual offenders.
In many other areas including national security, GOI appears to be a 'pushover' as it invariably avoids retaliatory action. Does not even declare its intention to discipline the offender.
While I am not suggesting that India should resort to use of military force at the slightest provocation/threat, there is an urgent need to at least warn the habitual offenders.
Monday, 29 August 2011
Error of Judgment
Salman Khurshid the Min of Law, himself a SC lawyer, has admitted to the government making an error of judgment in dealing with the civil society.
This sounds insincere as errors of judgment are usually made when judgment is exercised, which in this case no one did. Everyone was blaming everybody else; no one took responsibility. The PM was conspicuous by his absence in the first week.
This GOM or collegiate type of decision making can be problematic. In the past the PM stood up and took responsibility and handled a crisis with the help of his or her advisors and not vice versa.
Considering that the PM has declared mending relations with Pakistan as a major objective of his political career should he not add mending relations with his own people as an equally important goal?
In today's Indian Express, Jerry Rao has reminded the PM about how many of his predecessors had signed agreements with non-politicians. Rajiv-Longowal Acord, Rajiv-AASU Accord, Indira Gandhi-Sheikh Abdulla Accord etc. Worth a read for the PM.
It would be interesting to see how the Chairman of the Parliamentary Standing Committee Manu Singhvi, also a SC lawyer, now handles the hot potato of the JLPB. Many of his party colleagues are unlikely to accept Anna's suggestions with grace.
This sounds insincere as errors of judgment are usually made when judgment is exercised, which in this case no one did. Everyone was blaming everybody else; no one took responsibility. The PM was conspicuous by his absence in the first week.
This GOM or collegiate type of decision making can be problematic. In the past the PM stood up and took responsibility and handled a crisis with the help of his or her advisors and not vice versa.
Considering that the PM has declared mending relations with Pakistan as a major objective of his political career should he not add mending relations with his own people as an equally important goal?
In today's Indian Express, Jerry Rao has reminded the PM about how many of his predecessors had signed agreements with non-politicians. Rajiv-Longowal Acord, Rajiv-AASU Accord, Indira Gandhi-Sheikh Abdulla Accord etc. Worth a read for the PM.
It would be interesting to see how the Chairman of the Parliamentary Standing Committee Manu Singhvi, also a SC lawyer, now handles the hot potato of the JLPB. Many of his party colleagues are unlikely to accept Anna's suggestions with grace.
Sunday, 28 August 2011
Its cool to be honest
Pompous, sanctimonious, supercilious and condescending are not adequate adjectives to describe these pseudo-intellectuals who are even now questioning the sincerity of Anna's overall objective of ridding our society of corruption. people are fully aware that one bill alone cannot do that and hence will continue to remain vigilant. We do not need sermons from you. Be honest for once, and accept that the average Indian is beginning to change. As Chetan Bhagat has said, its cool to be honest. What a simple yet profound statement!!
A Half Victory but a Total Defeat?
All those who doubted Anna's credentials and disapproved of his methods have been proved wrong even if his followers have not won a full victory. All those who stubbornly ignored and later opposed the demands of the people by disingenuously calling them 'middle class exclusive urbanites' who did not represent the larger majority of the Indian citizenry and were in fact marginalizing the Dalits, minorities and the other depressed classes; an absolutely preposterous charge. These doubts and allegations were made/aised by those who believed that their brand of voe bank politics was supreme and could not be challenged ever.
Today, some editors are quoting critics and defendents alike to make the same point that even if the movement succeeded its demands that parliament pass what the civil society had wanted, was essentially undemocratic. I have great respect for Sharad Yadav and Om Puri. Shekhar Gupta in today's Indian Express cites Om Puri as calling the MPs Ganwars and gives Sharad Yadav's example as being a representative of the rustic classes. Gupta's argument is totally disingenuous. Sharad Yadav is not the right example as he is experienced, educated and wise and witty but what the civil society was objecting to were theMPs who got themselves elected on the promise of working for the depressed classes but in fact lined their own purse and wantonly robbed the country. Both the urban and rural backward types quickly learned the ropes and became wealthy and arrogant beyond belief. So Mr Gupta, please do not try to defend them. As I have asked before, "What if instead of 151 all 543 members of the LS have a record of serious criminal offenses?" Will Mr Gupta still defend them as being the supreme representatives of the supreme parliament. Mr Gupta, you have rightly recalled all that is wrong with vote bank politics and the attendant corruption. Why then this opposition to the people fighting for their rights as a last resort? Surely, had the ruling class been half as sensitive and honest the civil society would never have succeeded.
Today, some editors are quoting critics and defendents alike to make the same point that even if the movement succeeded its demands that parliament pass what the civil society had wanted, was essentially undemocratic. I have great respect for Sharad Yadav and Om Puri. Shekhar Gupta in today's Indian Express cites Om Puri as calling the MPs Ganwars and gives Sharad Yadav's example as being a representative of the rustic classes. Gupta's argument is totally disingenuous. Sharad Yadav is not the right example as he is experienced, educated and wise and witty but what the civil society was objecting to were theMPs who got themselves elected on the promise of working for the depressed classes but in fact lined their own purse and wantonly robbed the country. Both the urban and rural backward types quickly learned the ropes and became wealthy and arrogant beyond belief. So Mr Gupta, please do not try to defend them. As I have asked before, "What if instead of 151 all 543 members of the LS have a record of serious criminal offenses?" Will Mr Gupta still defend them as being the supreme representatives of the supreme parliament. Mr Gupta, you have rightly recalled all that is wrong with vote bank politics and the attendant corruption. Why then this opposition to the people fighting for their rights as a last resort? Surely, had the ruling class been half as sensitive and honest the civil society would never have succeeded.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)